This review as like the others I have recently posted were part of my assessment for the first semester of the year, by which we must write five critical reviews on films, theatre plays/performances or exhibitions. So here are my five reviews:
Dressed to Kill: Fashion, Costume and Dress in Scottish Art City Art Centre (Edinburgh Museums and Galleries) Edinburgh June 15-September 29 2013
Exhibited across two floors, Edinburgh’s City Art Centre exhibition Dressed to Kill is a feast for the eyes. The mixed media exhibition shows the work of Scottish artists, many of which studied either at Edinburgh College of Art or Glasgow School of Art. These works dating between the 18th and 20th centuries, making for a wide range of ideas, styles and techniques presented within the exhibition. As indicated in the name of the exhibit, the works having been put together show the change and diversity within the world of fashion through time. Approaching the art works on floor one, the viewer realises a theme of narrative. Many of the paintings are outlining a story whether fictional or not; from ‘Tristam and Isolde’ by John Duncan, which is based on a Celtic myth to ‘In the picture gallery’ by Sir William Quiller-Orchardson, which is based on a true love story. Equal to this the works are also sub-divided accordingly. There is a section of works which have been put together that invite the viewer to recognise the differences between the characters within the work. There are portraits of incredibly wealthy ladies and gentlemen alongside portraits of impoverished members of society. A most striking comparison I made myself was the work of Allan Ramsay ‘Katherine Hall of Dunglass’, this painting having been done as a commission has Katherine Hall standing with good posture and holding a spear diagonally across her body, this expressing the message of authority and power. As well as this the garment she is wearing is a dark rose pink, a rich colour as to communicate wealth along with the background of the painting being a vast area of farm land, indicating that she owns the land. In great contrast, the painting alongside; ‘A Newhaven Fishwife’ by Alfred H Green, is a portrait of a woman who has been aged by her work, here she is seen gutting fish, her clothes are dirty and worn and her life style nothing like that of Katherine Hall. Although being significantly contrasting I felt that this installation setting worked well in allowing the audience to directly compare the art instead of merely looking at a series of work showing wealthy society and then a series of work showing poor society.
Continuing through the first floor are two smaller sections of work. The first being a number of works ranging from the 1820’s to 1930’s and these showed glimpses of Edinburgh’s history: photographs, paintings and drawings showing what various areas of the city looked like at the time of the work being created.
The last section, containing my favourite art works on the floor was based upon narratives of children. Firstly ‘Seashore Roses’ by Edward Atkinson Hornel, this is a beautiful piece of work, painted with oils the artists style shows evidence of quite large brush strokes with thickly applied paint giving the effect of being part of the scene, a great use of colour well depicts shadow, I felt like I was with the characters, I was by the sea. The characters are three little girls who are picking and smelling the roses that are surrounding them. All lounged within the long grass with the seashore in the background on a bright sunny day. I look at this painting and just smile, they are the image of peace and happiness and it fills me with joy to view it.
Secondly I really liked the work ‘Flight of the Shadows’ by John Henry Lorimer. The feeling of the painting being in great contrast to ‘Seashore Roses’, there is a quiet sadness when looking at the work. This painting shows two little girls with their mother looking out of the window for shadows, while a older girl sits on the ledge of the window crying, this I feel gave a message of children developing into adults. The older girl seems unable to join her sisters with their activity, as if she has the awful feeling of being too mature for such childish actions. This painting also reminded me of Peter Pan, all the characters are at the window, in search of the fairy- tale character.
Differing from this floor, floor two lead you down a different theme route. Varieties of media art works have been exhibited together (paintings, photography, pencil/pastel drawings) which gives this part of the exhibition more diversity but due to an underlying theme of identity the pieces seem to jigsaw together nicely. Identity being a theme as the artists are showing a part of themselves within their work, and not just in the way of their artistic style. Either they are creating self portraits/portraits of a loved one or are showing an opinion through the persons actions within the work.
On entering the viewer first encountered two paintings of complimentary style. ‘Marjorie’ by Alfred Edward Borthwick was shown alongside ‘Dreams’ by William Strang. Both being similar size canvas, done in oil paints and the styles echo each other in the way that both artists paint realistic almost photographic looking paintings, completed with small, delicate brush strokes. Equally the characters within the painting have a similar pose/ composition so the two echo each other well.
Next a small section of paintings also have a secondary subject of their work in common, this being a female model. It can be identified to that the women present within the works are wealthy due to their on trend fashion sense as well as their surroundings, whether it be a home interior or at a party. My favourite work on this floor is ‘The Black Hat’ by Francis Campbell Boileau Cadell. The quick brush strokes give the painting a sense movement, the painting shows the character in front of (but not looking into) a mirror. The reflection has been perfectly captured. The whole piece of work just gives a sense of happiness and celebration. The character is dressed particularly well, as if to be going out to have an excellent time. This section also contains the work of Stanley Cursiter, George Telfer Bear and Francis H Newberry.
Another cluster of works are related to school children, this section includes historic and contemporary photography which allows the audience to really easily make comparisons between school days in the 19th century and 20th century. One series of works that I find fascinating is ‘Computer Class 1 and 2’ by Wendy McMurdo. These two photographs are of a school child, each within their own bedrooms. Their positions are as if they are working on a computer but the computers have been digitally removed from the photograph. This I felt was McMurdo’s way of expressing/suggesting that children are continuously being seen with pieces of technology, these are considered the ‘toys’ of a child’s childhood. It has been cleverly set within a child’s room that contains non electronic toys. Also the two photographs have been exhibited alongside each other showing the characters in both photos to be back to back. This I thought related well as it gave a sense of a break down in community, children less often play together due to the use of such technologies. This work was a prime example of the artist expressing their opinion through their work.
The final section of the exhibition contained portraits either of the artists or their loved ones. The painting that stood out for me within this section was ‘Sisters Emma and Janet’ by William George Gilles, the reason for this was because it reminded me of the portrait of the Bronte sisters painted by Branwell Bronte. A very traditional portrait style while others where more visually pleasing due to a strong use of colour like the work of Moyna Flannigan ‘Happy Valley’, this being a painting completed from memory which looked almost photographic the detail is so delicate and the use of colour very strong.
Overall I really enjoyed seeing this exhibition, I felt is allowed the audience to compare the work easily as to fully understand each sub-sections of the artworks as well as to explore into the stories or messages behind each piece of art work. I believe anyone interested in art, particularly that of paintings will be thrilled to experience this exhibition, on the other hand some viewers who prefer the work of contemporary artists may feel that it is lacking artworks of a more conceptual and edgy style. All in all I would recommend anyone, artist or not to go and see the exhibition.